Not all mushroom supplements are created equal

How to choose a quality mushroom supplement.

From fruiting bodies to beta-glucan content and third-party testing, here’s what to look for to ensure your mushroom supplement is safe, potent, and worth your investment.

The global mushroom supplement market is booming—but not all products deliver what they promise. A 2017 study found that nearly 75% of Reishi supplements contained significantly fewer bioactive compounds than labeled, and many were diluted with starch or fillers.[1] To confidently choose a mushroom supplement, you need to focus on transparency, testing, and extraction methods rooted in evidence.

What to look for in a high-quality mushroom supplement

When choosing a mushroom supplement, start with the ingredients. Look for products made from fruiting bodies—the part of the mushroom rich in triterpenes and other beneficial compounds—rather than mycelium grown on grain, which is often diluted with starch. Potency matters, too: aim for supplements with clearly labeled beta-glucan content of at least 20–30%, as these polysaccharides are key to immune support and overall efficacy.[2][3]

Equally important is how the supplement is made and verified. High-quality products use dual extraction (hot water and ethanol) to pull out the full spectrum of active compounds, and they provide third-party lab results confirming purity and potency.[4][5] Trusted brands are transparent about every step—from sourcing and DNA verification to processing and packaging—and clearly label details like mushroom species, extraction ratios, and certifications, ensuring what’s on the label matches what’s in the bottle.[6]

Discover mushroom supplements that work for you, not against you.

Explore more →
The Bottom Line

Make informed choices when shopping for mushroom supplements

With so many options on the market, quality matters more than ever. Look for supplements made from fruiting bodies, not just mycelium; aim for 20% or more beta-glucans; prioritize dual-extracted formulas; and always seek out transparent, third-party testing. These steps help ensure your supplement is safe, effective, and aligned with your wellness values.

Sources

  1. Scientific Reports, Evaluation on quality consistency of Ganoderma lucidum dietary supplements collected in the United States

  2. WholeSun Wellness, Guide to mushroom fruiting bodies & benefits

  3. Real Mushrooms, What is beta-D-glucan?

  4. Lucid, Dual extract mushroom vs. hot water extract: Which is best for mushroom supplements?

  5. Antioxi Supplements, The ultimate guide to mushroom quality

  6. LabVantage Solutions, The importance of maintaining chain of custody and audit trails